Tag: mystery book’
Book: ‘The Scarlet Letters’ by Ellery Queen – June 26tyh, 2016
by Rob Smith, Jr. on Jun.26, 2016, under What's New?
The Scarlet Letters by Ellery Queen
My rating: 2 of 5 stars
I love the Queen series. i just picked up another clump of them. This is one of them. However, this is not an example of the reason i picked up so many.
This Queen tale is waaaaaaay too prolonged with an involved MaGuffin that seems orderly enough, but gets monotonous quickly as little else happens involving, what appears to be, a domestic dispute. The story doesn’t make sense unless Queen jumps to too many assumptions. which is something he warns not to do in many of the Queen novels. This is a repeated inconsistency that is the only way the writers could link events, but a flimsy one and one that had me find the entire tale ridiculous.
Due to the prolonged trip through the alphabet, the few characters are very well identified. Odd that the few settings, that are repeated many times, did not have the detail they could have.
The ending is very unsatisfying considering all it took to get to the point. All proving this would have been a far better short story.
Bottom line: I don’t recommend this book. 5 out of 5 points.
Book: ‘Burke’s Law: Who Killed Madcap Millicent?’ by Roger Fuller – December 3rd, 2015
by Rob Smith, Jr. on Dec.03, 2015, under Books
Who Killed Madcap Millicent? by Roger Fuller
My rating: 4 of 5 stars
I did my best to put out of mind Gene Berry’s Amos Burke, but his voice fit so well with Fuller’s writing, that he stayed throughout. Thus revealing the fine job Fuller did re-creating the televised character to novel form. That is Fuller’s specialty, turning that on film to written novels. This book is an example at his great ability and success.
This story is very good and entirely misses the nasty trappings of the contemporary novels of excessive writing and lack of editing. The story is very tight, yet leaving a vast cast of characters and a very nice mystery. Though, I’m usually figuring out the end early, here i did not. This done without various typical literary devices as twists and shell games. This story involves a set of quintuplets. Most mystery writers would use this to confuse the reader. Not in this case, which makes the ending that much better.
The characters are well written, with a few exceptions. Unfortunately the exceptions seem to be the regular cast, with exception of Amos Burke. Burke’s driver and other of the police force are lightly touched upon, then left to the imagination. The settings are also loosely defined.
Bottom line: I recommend this book. 8 out of 10 points.
September 14th, 2015 – Book: ‘Murder Fantastical’ by Patricia Moyes
by Rob Smith, Jr. on Sep.14, 2015, under Books
Murder Fantastical by Patricia Moyes
My rating: 3 of 5 stars
I do like this Tibbetts series and this one was as much fun as the last I read.
The mystery starts off very slowly. There’s meandering all over, in and out, up and down, ad around the Manciple family. The family is interesting, just, to me, not that interesting. All of the meandering leads to very well defined characters. Especially impressive due to a very large cast.
The settings are well illustrated. The locations are few and two major settings are particularly well told.
Bottom line: I recommend this book: 6 out of 10 points.
#CurrentlyReading ‘Night Ferry to Death’ by Patricia Moyes.
by Rob Smith, Jr. on Sep.05, 2015, under Books
Leave a Comment :book, Books, British mystery, British mystery book, English mystery, Jacob Smith, mystery book', Patricia Moyes., Rob Smith Jr, Taylor Smith more...November 20th, 2014 – Book: ‘Morse’s Greatest Mystery and Other Stories’ by Colin Dexter.
by Rob Smith, Jr. on Nov.20, 2014, under Books
Morse’s Greatest Mystery and Other Stories by Colin Dexter
My rating: 5 of 5 stars
I’m not usually a fan of a short story collection, but this one is outstanding. I also don’t give five stars lightly. I feel the overall book deserves them. I’ll add that not all may love this set of stories. Those who love real mysteries will love these. Those who love James Patterson or Sandra Brown are likely not to like them.
Dexter really has a flair for crafting a short mystery. No easy task. Sorry there is only one collection of short stories. Still hope for more from Dexter.
The tales in the book are all mysteries with great characters, stories and terrific writing.
Bottom line: I recommend the book!
November 16th, 2014 – Book’ The Case of the Lame Canary’ by Erle Stanley Gardner.
by Rob Smith, Jr. on Nov.19, 2014, under Books
The Case of the Lame Canary by Erle Stanley Gardner
My rating: 3 of 5 stars
What stands out as the best parts of ‘The Case of the Lame Canary is the interaction between the Perry Mason, Della Street and Paul Drake characters. Gardcner is at the top of his writing skills with consistency and character development.
This is also true of the rest of the cast of this novel. Distinct characters developed throughout the book. This all helps wading through a very convoluted and overly concocted story by Gardner.
This book revels Gardeners ability to write great characterized and his ability to work too hard to use elements to create a book.
As I read the book I could see how Gardner had a set of distinct parts he worked real hard to fit together. This makes the book feel very forced to a conclusion. You know there is a conclusion at the end, but keep seeing many pages ahead as Gardner tries to weave in some nonsense leads that,in any other of his books, Mason would have been written to figure out.
Though I don’t care for the overall story, the writing is top notch and,again, just reading character interaction is outstanding.
Bottom line: I recommend this book. 6 of 10 points.
February 17th, 2014 – Book: ‘The Red House Mystery’ by A.A. Milne
by Rob Smith, Jr. on Feb.17, 2014, under Books
The Red House Mystery by A.A. Milne
My rating: 1 of 5 stars
I an see why a.A. Milne didn’t see another mystery published. This one is a mighty stretch of reality that is poorly written and seems to have been written as the writer was thin king it all out.
The story opens well and i settled in with what I suspected a mystery in an English setting. Instead, I find myself, after the evil is done, slogging through, what seems, endless patter about what-might-have-happened, what-could-have-have-happened, who-did-it, who-didn’t, etc. All of this barely moving the story along at all for decades of pages.
Worse, the characters are never defined except for the beginning. Making this all worse involves two main characters who pretend to be Holmes and Watson. Seems Milne knew he had troubles defining characters, so he uses others to do it for him.
The solution is intellectually dishonest. Today would be impossible, but pretty hard to believe that such a mistake could have been made even in the 1920s.
Bottom line: I do not recommend this book.
January 22nd, 2012 – Book: The Toff and the Deadly Parson.
by Rob Smith, Jr. on Jan.22, 2013, under Books
The Toff and the Deadly Parson by John Creasey
My rating: 3 of 5 stars
Am excellent mystery that will keep you guessing throughout. The writing is good, but for a contemporary American crowd, probably over their heads. Also, the contemporary American crowd are used to having a book written with someone connected to a church being the natural bad guy which will throw them as the book weaves around so many curves. Creasey crafted this well and it’s smartly written for an audience who is willing to pay attention to all that goes on. Too bad writers like Patterson can’t reach these heights.
July 12th, 2012 – Book: Hit Man by Lawrence Block
by Rob Smith, Jr. on Jul.12, 2012, under Books
My rating: 4 of 5 stars
Block’s book is nearly a travel journal as the main character roams about doing his job and trying to figure out his place in life. As each trip is logged in another story starts within the book. The stories aren’t broken into specific named chapters. The overall book contains probably a dozen tales of the adventures of the character. I wonder if that was the original thought. To have a series of short stories for a magazine or some such. Overall it is very good. Well written. Well defined characters. The interaction of the main character and the main contact for his work is nearly magic. The writing there is simply superb.
March 31st, 2012 – Book: Always Say Goodbye by Stuart Kaminsky
by Rob Smith, Jr. on Mar.31, 2012, under Books
Always Say Goodbye by Stuart M. Kaminsky
My rating: 3 of 5 stars
This is the first I’ve read of the Stuart Kaminsky series involving Lew Fonesca that otherwise takes place in Sarasota. This entry in the series, though, mostly takes place in Chicago as the main character looks for the murderer of his wife. The writing is well done. Especially in getting the Chicago dialogue to read true. There are a number of twists. One twist involving one character is especially well done. Also, this is not an overwritten novel as so many others are today.